Lipreading…Easy?

Earlier we spoke about general myths that many have about the deaf, and one area that people tend to have misunderstandings about is lipreading. As one might imagine, it is a very difficult skill to master. For starters, 60% of the English language is simply not visible on the lips, which places one attempting to lip read at a significant disadvantage before they have even begun!  If that wasn’t challenging enough, there are several other things to contend with. If you consider the variety in human faces, you have a good idea of what must be overcome… such as fat or thin lips, mustaches and beards or other facial quirks or features. Then of course there are variations in speech, from something as simple as mumbling to more elaborate complications like foreign language speakers. Other obvious issues include the level of lighting in the room, distance from the speaker, how quickly they speak and the extent of their vocabulary.

Now, there are some things that improve the success of the lipreader. One significant factor is how familiar the deaf person is with the topic. Another is how well they know the person they are attempting to lip read. With that in mind, if you don’t know ASL it is still better to gesture than assume that talking to a deaf person is sufficient.  This is made worse by the fact that hearing people tend to over exaggerate or talk loud when they are conversing with a deaf or hard of hearing person.

One of the ways that deaf people deal with this situation is to anticipate what people are going to ask or say, keeping in mind the context where the conversation is taking place. For example, if a deaf person were to be pulled over by the police, he or she would predict what the officer was going to ask, such as requesting their driver’s license, vehicle registration and certificate of insurance. Then again, if the officer were to ask something completely random to the situation, like a question about their mother, the deaf person would have difficulty understanding that by lipreading, even with the use of gestures.

Many more examples or explanations could be given, but the main things, as always, is to gain a better understanding of what it is like to be deaf to help inform your interactions with members of the community. Perhaps you might like to try it sometime with a friend by blocking your hearing and seeing if you can repeat back even 10% of what they said?  Chances are your struggle to understand will give you yet one more reason to learn American Sign Language!

3 thoughts on “Lipreading…Easy?

  1. Most lip-readers adopt numerous ways of following the spoken word. The key is PLANNING ! we have to be specialist as pre-empting conversations that you know you may not follow, keep questions and answers very basic,do NOT pre-amble and allow too much in-depth you will lose the plot. Details you ensure you get BEFORE any meeting, that way you can frame your conversation to cover all but a few minor aspects you aren’t interested in or not relevant anyway. It is an art form. Lip reading is 30% effective at best,most of us never attain that classes here do not set any levels to achieve. I understand the plug for sign language, and I can make my way with it, BUT ! if you live in a area where not a single person understands sign language then how effective is that. Most of us do not live in a deaf community or near one. Lip-reading is all we have that is remotely effective in that case.

  2. Love it – I agree – I will be sharing this! Great blog and I suggest you keep up the good work! Thanks for sharing this with us! – Jim Beach

  3. As a hard of hearing person who spent the first 7 years of my life having to lip read, this makes me feel better. I always wondered, and maybe you can answer this, how I ended up teaching my family member to lip read too? Everyone I lived with has ended up learning from me and I don’t honestly know how (I’m talking about my husband, siblings and cousin).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>